Note: I originally wrote this record review in early 2004, when the long-delayed
Smile was released. However, at that time I had no place to post it; now I do.
"God is not subtle." Albert Einstein. But could God have a sense of humor?A REVIEW OF SMILEOK, so first of all, forget everything you've read or heard about this being Brian Wilson's
Sgt. Pepper's album. This is not
Sgt. Pepper's -
Pet Sounds was that and more - but another
Abbey Road, side two.
Side two of the Beatles'
Abbey Road was basically a collection of unfinished songs, ideas for songs that Paul McCartney called "bites." Brian Wilson called his song ideas "bits" and today, in the age of digital recording, they might appropriately be called "bytes," but that's another story. (The idea of playing song pieces derives from the English music hall and American burlesque halls, where musicians who ran out of sheet music to play filled in with their ideas for future songs.)
Smile is a collection of bites and bits and more; and like
Pet Sounds and
Sgt. Pepper's the work is more than the sum of its parts. It is a collection of musical ideas intended - like the Who's
Tommy or
Chicago II - to be experienced by the listener as one piece, from start to finish, for better or worse.
Let me get the worst out of the way right now. The biggest flaw with
Smile is Brian's need, then and now, to show us what a comprehensive student of music he is. The pivotal and repeating "Heroes and Villains" theme borrows from Prokofiev's "Peter and the Wolf." Further, as we listen we hear the influences of Leonard Bernstein, Aaron Copeland, Gershwin, Erik Satie, Mozart, Dvorak, movie soundtracks such as
How the West Was Won, casino crooners, Spike Jones and his City Slickers, and the colored vinyl children's records that Brian first digested. Some also hear Bach and/or Schubert.
It is all, at first, a bit too much, a kitchen sink approach to music. Just like the 23 tracks on the symphony-like
Chicago II was at first too much, especially with the producer's note: "This endeavor should be experienced sequentially." But the more you listened, the more the whole effort made sense and eventually you couldn't consider re-arranging the track order.
This is what happens with
Smile. Initially, it seems too cute, too bloated and busy. But then you remember the very appropriate title of this collection, and the original album art that looked very much like the cover of a children's book.
Oh... This isn't meant to be SERIOUS, this is for fun, deliberately childlike and childish in a deliberately non-grown up way.
Come to think of it, too much of our music is far too serious. From Springsteen's post-9/11
The Rising, to Sinatra's aging album
September of Our Years ("Tonight is not for fun, tonight is for serious..." said the liner notes), to personal and brilliant but troubling confessionals like Bob Dylan's
Blood on the Tracks and Joni Mitchell's
Blue, it is all too serious. It is all so tiredly adult.
So,
Smile isn't Paul Simon's
Graceland nor Peter Gabriel's
Us, but it is equally life-affirming when heard with a different ear; a child's ear, before the end of the innocence. (Interestingly, like those two albums,
Smile is acceptingly multicultural and not Anglo-Saxon ethno-centric.)
Smile is not one of those hard to absorb albums about the weariness of life or life's losses or heavy lessons. It's not a divorce album or an album about eventual survival or death. It is a simple collection of songs about enjoying life simply ("eat your vegetables") and having fun. Let's play that funny horn and make silly noises! Let's pretend to fly! I'll be Davy Crockett!
Smile is an album dedicated to the enjoyment of music, the enjoyment of life no matter how short - even if your siblings (like two of Brian's) pre-decease you. Enjoy life even if the worst is going to happen, when you grow up someday.
Smile tells us that music is enough.
Smile reminds us that life is a miracle and so this music is Brian's prayer, his tribute, a child's contribution to God. A simple prayer, a fun prayer, a prayer meant to make even God smile.
Smile is not a masterpiece, but for human beings it is close enough.
Thank you, Brian.